Coffee shop interior with warm lighting
Sellersburg, Indiana

Small-town roots.
Big-city roast.

We roast every batch right here in Sellersburg — no corporate supply chain, no middleman. Just coffee that tastes like it was made for this town, because it was.

View Our Menu Find Us
100% Locally Roasted
Daily Fresh Baked
Since Sellersburg
Latte art being poured at Starlight Coffee
Today's Pour Single-origin Ethiopian
Freshly roasted coffee beans
Roasted Small batch, every morning
Scroll to explore
Interior of Starlight Coffee Co. & Roastery
Coffee roaster in operation
Proudly Sellersburg
Our Story

Built on a belief that
great coffee starts
at home.

Starlight Coffee Co. & Roastery was born from a simple conviction: the best coffee doesn't need a big-city address to be exceptional. It needs patience, quality beans, and a community that cares.

We set up shop on Old Indiana 60 because Sellersburg felt like the right place — a town where neighbors still greet each other by name and where a cup of coffee is more than a habit, it's a ritual. Every bean we roast, every pastry we bake, every grocery item on our shelves is chosen with that same local-first mindset.

When you walk through our doors, you're not a transaction. You're part of the story we're writing together, one cup at a time.

Roasted in-house Every batch, every day, right here in Sellersburg.
Community-focused A space built for neighbors, by neighbors.
Quality-first Premium beans, fresh bakes, curated groceries.
The Roastery

Where every bean
gets a second act.

Our roastery is the heartbeat of Starlight Coffee. This is where green beans become something worth writing home about. We roast in small batches so every bag that leaves our shop carries the same attention to detail we'd give our own morning cup.

We source directly from growers who treat their land and their workers with respect. Then we bring those beans home to Sellersburg, where we profile each origin to bring out its best character — whether that's a bright, fruity Ethiopian or a deep, chocolatey Brazilian.

01
Sourcing Direct-trade relationships with farms across Ethiopia, Colombia, Brazil, and Guatemala.
02
Roasting Small-batch roasting with custom profiles developed for each origin and varietal.
03
Quality Control Every batch is cupped and evaluated before it's approved for packaging and sale.
04
Packaging Sealed within 24 hours of roasting to lock in freshness and flavor.
Coffee beans being roasted Freshly roasted coffee beans cooling Coffee being packaged for sale
Community Voices

What our neighbors say

"I've been coming to Starlight every morning for two years now. The coffee is consistently excellent, and the staff remembers my order before I even sit down. It's our town's best-kept secret — and we're not keeping it secret anymore."

Sarah M. Sellersburg resident

"The single-origin pour-over changed how I think about coffee. I didn't know beans could taste that different from roast to roast. Now I'm buying bags to take home and I've introduced half my office to Starlight."

James T. Local business owner

"As a baker, I appreciate someone who takes their craft seriously. The sourdough here is legitimately restaurant-quality, and the pastry selection rotates in ways that keep me coming back. This place gets it."

Maria L. Local baker
Visit Us

Come say
hello

Address 7613 Old Indiana 60
Sellersburg, IN 47172
Hours Monday – Friday: 6:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Send Us a Message

Have a question about our roasts, want to order for an event, or just want to say hi? Drop us a line.

Thanks for reaching out! We'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Is this your business?This is my business